Featured post

Crusade – What the Hell Happened Next – The Unproduced Episodes

INTRODUCTION

Crusade was the first spin-off produced following the end of Babylon 5. It suffered greatly at the hands of TNT executives and what made it to the screen was a compromised show in many respects. That said, Crusade was based around a good premise and had a decent set of characters, it just never had a chance to live up to its full potential. Imagine if Babylon 5 had been cancelled thirteen episodes in, it would have been a minor footnote in SF TV history and forever dismissed as a Star Trek clone…

Before continuing, I’d highly suggest you watch the produced episodes to get the most out of the analysis of the unproduced scripts (I’d suggest the Continuity Order of course). Once you’ve watched all the produced episodes, you’ll be left without any kind of conclusion of course, but also with many questions left unanswered, and many implications for interesting storylines that could have developed.

In the 22 years since the show, we’ve since learned some of the direction the show was due to take. Crusade was planned to expand far beyond the initial “quest for the cure” aspect of the show. This information has come, drip by drip, in the form of unproduced scripts, story outlines, canonical novels and information in multiple books, interviews, his autobiography and even JMS tweets. I won’t mention anything right now, but trust me, if you don’t know any of it (or even just a little), it’s worth trying to find the scripts and go through them. It gives you a more complete image of how the first season of Crusade would have played out.

The following episodes would have completed the first season:

  • S01E14 – “To the Ends of the Earth” – Fully scripted – J Michael Straczynski
  • S01E15 – “Value Judgments” – Fully scripted – Fiona Avery
  • S01E16 – “Darkness of the Soul” – Planned only – J Michael Straczynski to write
  • S01E17 – “Tried and True” – Fully scripted – J Michael Straczynski
  • S01E18 – “Untitled” – Planned only – J Michael Straczynski to write
  • S01E19 – “War Story” (Sword Trilogy, Part 1) – Outline / Spec. script – Richard Mueller
  • S01E20 – “The Walls of Hell” (Sword Trilogy, Part 2) – Partial Outline only – Larry DiTillio
  • S01E21 – “Untitled” (Sword Trilogy, Part 3) – Planned only – JMS to write
  • S01E22 – “The End of the Line” – Fully scripted – J Michael Straczynski

In addition, there is a script which was written for the first season, but was bumped for use in the second season and replaced with “Tried and True”:

  • S02EXX – “Little Bugs Have Lesser Bugs” – Fully scripted – Peter Woodward

Of these episode scripts and outlines, most have either been released online or as part of the Babylon 5 / Crusade Script Book releases.

Babylon-5-Crusade-Books-190607

In the spirit of fairness with those who have spent their hard-earned cash on the script books, these reviews will not contain transcripts nor images solely available in the Script Book releases. I apologize if that’s what you’re looking for in this article

All the scripts were finally released through the B5books website. While the book “Crusade: What the Hell Happened Vol 1” had a wealth of info on the behind the scenes goings on it stopped short of telling the full story. The subsequent “Crusade: What the Hell Happened Vols 2 and 3” contained the unproduced scripts and did not continue the behind the scenes tales unfortunately. JMS’s autobiography “Becoming Superman” is a fantastic read, but sadly the information on Crusade is nothing new.

Reviewing a script isn’t quite the same as a completed episode. The production of an episode from script to screen can result in changes for many reasons: budgetary considerations, over-runs, actor availability and rewrites to name but a few. So any review has to accept that you’re not really examining a finished item, and there would likely have been changes, for better or worse, during production. While scripts feature many notes on the effects and camera shots, you don’t get the benefit of the finished score, direction, cinematography, editing, effects and acting – so that’s another factor to keep in mind.

Without further delay, let’s get back to the bridge of the Excalibur and see where we’ll be taken next…

< Crusade – The Continuity Order Conclusion | Next Script “To the Ends of the Earth” >

Crusade: Season 2 and Beyond

So the preceding pages were about everything I could find on what was produced for the remainder of Crusade Season 1. It’s not a complete picture and while the quality of the unproduced scripts seemed mixed, they are mostly just rough drafts. The quality in the completed scripts (“To the Ends of the Earth,” “Value Judgements” and “The End of the Line”) are as good as some of the best of Babylon 5. It’s obvious they were building up to a strong finish, the twists and turns were just beginning.

Known Future Storylines

From what information has been shared over the last two decades, we know season two would have featured the following two major events:

1. The Curing of the Drakh Plague

JMS has stated numerous times now, that the Drakh plague would be cured in Season 2. I’m not sure if the Excalibur crew would be directly responsible or not. 

2. The Excalibur on the Run

Following their discovery of secret Earthforce experiments with Shadow technology and their attempt to expose the conspiracy (either directly because of the events of “The End of the Line” or subsequent events), the crew are framed by those same elements. They crew “liberate” the Excalibur and avoid capture.

Whether all the crew would go on the run, the Interstellar Alliance would take assist them (Byron’s experience says otherwise), or one of a million other possibilities, isn’t known. An intriguing possibility for me, is that Captain Lochley might have lead the hunt. She’s a “by the book” type who sided with Clark in the civil war because she “doesn’t set policy”. I think her personal relationship would have also made her a good candidate for tracking Gideon…

(credit to

Potential Future Storylines

I don’t particularly believe the remaining 3 seasons would have simply been the Excalibur crew flitting all over the galaxy, trying to clearing their name and acting like a cross between Blake’s 7 and The A-Team. So one, or possibly a combination of the options below could have become the main antagonists and threat for the remainder of the show:

The Drakh and Shadow Servant Races

While their plague is defeated, revenge is still on the menu. While only personal opinion, I felt like the Drakh weren’t good villains – certainly not to the level of the Shadows, the Vorlons, the Psi Corps or even the Thirdspace aliens. Their introduction in B5 fell flat, the ship design was mediocre, the prosthetics looked like something out of the Power Rangers and they barely even featured in the entirety of season 1 of Crusade. I hope once the plague problem was solved, they weren’t involved much more, but who knows.

The Earthforce Black Operations

Their scale and influence shows they are no minor threat. They are jealously guarding their knowledge, abilities and power – what their final goal is for that power isn’t clear. That they frame the Excalibur crew showed they would likely continue to have a large presence in the show.

Dureena’s and her Abilities

Dureena might have become a wild card herself, as we know little of the technology and abilities she possesses after her return from the White Ship. Might it have unexpected implications or effects on her? I believe her and Galen would have continued in a mentor/mentee relationship, maybe becoming an actual relationship?

The Technomages

The Technomages have a few issues that might bring them into conflict with the Excalibur:

  1. The potential of their secrets being exposed. Some elements never liked Galen’s involvement in affairs beyond their hiding place and this may be a catalyst.
  2. Depending on the implications of Dureena’s new sword and implants, she may be seen as a threat or an opportunity to gain new technology to any rogue Mages. If he mentors her, that may have brought up further potential conflict with Technomage culture.
  3. The Technomages no longer had the ability to create new Technomages once the Shadows left. Dureena’s new implants could be looked upon as a potential avenue to creating new Technomages. However, a line in the Babylon 5 RPG “The Technomages” brings up an intriguing idea (whether canon or not.) It states: “There are rumours that members of the order have begun to engage in discussions with some of the EarthForce groups still studying Shadow-tech, but this is unconfirmed.”

The White Ship

While I feel like they might just be a red herring “first one” style race who are never seen again, but given JMS’s past twists (Sigma 957) – who’s to say?

Telepaths

While Bester in “Value Judgements” is his usual shady self and there are remnants of Psi Corps still looking for a fight, I would have guessed this was not likely to be a major component. However, from “What the Hell Happened – Book 1” is a quote: “From the second season onwards (I think 2nd season), Telepaths were going to become a larger component of the show.” How that would have manifested isn’t known.

The other potential issue here is the new Bureau of Telepath Integration. Despite being the replacement for the broken Psi Corps system, they seem to operate almost autonomously and may have an unknown agenda.

Something New Entirely

JMS may well have introduced a completely new plotline incorporating a new race, or new technology that becomes the focus of the show, but I don’t see him doing that when so much background was set up in Crusade Season 1.

The Apocalypse Box(es)

While I think most of the above factions would have been involved in multiple permutations, my best guess is the big denouement would have revolved around these curious little conundrums. We’ve already seen the Box have information that it shouldn’t have, it’s taken control of Matheson, seems to share information only when it suits a plan only it is privy to. It’s previous owners tend to die shortly after disposing of it/serve it’s purpose…

The following are points that were collect on the B5 wikia site and I’m repeating here:

  • According to J. Michael Straczynski, the Apocalypse Box would go on to play a significant role later on on the show and that for a time, Gideon would become “trapped” inside the box following his death during the season one cliffhanger (“End of the Line”).
  • The voice of the Apocalypse Box was provided by Gary Cole, foreshadowing Gideon’s consciousness being trapped inside for a time
  • Furthermore, in an interview given early on in Crusade’s production, Straczynski revealed that the Apocalypse Box is one of a set of six – and that everyone who has ever owned one has died “under mysterious and, usually, hideous circumstances.” Perhaps more disturbingly, Gideon’s ownership of the box was planned – by two separate individuals; one who wanted to get rid of it, and another who wanted Gideon to have it. Galen would have eventually found out about the Box, confronted Gideon with knowledge of its dangers, and most likely attempted to take it – not for his own use, but to dispose of it.

Another source of information on the Apocalypse Boxes is from the Mongoose “Babylon 5 Role Playing Game”. There have been multiple disagreements between those who produced the game and JMS himself over “canonicity” – with the writers insistent that everything was vetted as canon before publishing and JMS denying this. The information is certainly interesting and “feels” right to me (if that matters):

  • “During the Shadow War of 1250 (CE), a telepathic race known as the Shierren were working with the Shadows – instead they tried to control the First Ones somehow. On learning of their treachery, the Shadows bombarded their planet. The Shierren placed their ‘essences’ inside sixteen durable containers as a way to escape the total destruction of their race.
  • These Apocalypse Boxes (as they came to be known) were ejected into space in hopes of avoiding the Shadow’s wrath. Some were destroyed, others lost in hyperspace and only six were known to remain. These would resurface to wreak their own brand of havoc from time to time.
  • Each box contains a single mental presence of one elite Shierren telepath (P12). The Box would talk to its owner with sinister intention amplified by centuries of loneliness and madness. The individuals have only two goals – their own survival and taking action against the influence of the First Ones whenever possible. During its ownership by Captain Gideon, it caused the destruction of several lower races touched by the First Ones in the process.”

If truly canon we there’s some interesting implications here:

  • The biggest definitely being: “During its ownership by Captain Gideon, it caused the destruction of several lower races touched by the First Ones in the process.” Now that is some major plot points going on. SEVERAL races.
  • “taking action against the influence of the First Ones whenever possible” – which of the races we’ve seen in Babylon 5 and Crusade haven’t been influenced by the First Ones?
  • They’ve been stuck in those boxes for a thousand years…

There is also a large section in the “Crusade” supplement for the RPG that tells the history of the Shierren in more detail, it adds nothing very substantial that might have come into play for Crusade, beyond this paragraph below:

  • “Six hundred years before the construction of the last of the Babylon Stations, 1623 A.D. in Earth time, an alien transport passed through the fringes of the Tal-kona’sha realm, three light-years out from the former homeworld of the Shierren. The derelict was recovered and the Apocalypse Boxes were taken aboard. Despite the best intentions of the race that discovered them, the personalities inside the Boxes had changed since the original imprint countless centuries before. The memory of what they had once been was lost to the entities within the Boxes. Over the eons some of them became mentally unhinged, with little rhyme or reason to their decisions. With such fragmented mental patterns, the entities within the Boxes found it beneficial to have an owner, an individual with whom to form a close psychic bond, unknown to the host. The personalities within the Boxes felt this was right, not aware that this was how their predecessors, the true Shierren, had dominated their society.”

So, according to the RPG information above, the Boxes have a hatred of the First Ones, but it might be more instinctual, rather than a driving need for vengeance. However, as stated above, the canonicity of the RPG information is iffy and the Box in Gideon’s possession didn’t seem unhinged to me (in fact, the box had the correct number of hinges).

Things we know that definitely happened after Crusade’s Five Years

We don’t know what becomes of the Excalibur and most of her crew. Do they live? Do they die? Are they portrayed as heroes or villains? All we can do is try to extrapolate from what we saw and what we see set in the Babylon 5 universe after Crusade’s five year run:

  • In the Lost Tales, we see Galen standing on an Earth that is not obviously plague-ridden and quite alive, so we know that both the plague gets cured, and Galen survives
  • In the Lost Tales, we see Lochley alive and commanding Babylon 5.
  • From the Lost Tales and Sleeping in Light – Earthforce and the Earth Alliance appear to still be functioning in much the same way as before Crusade, so events in the subsequent seasons don’t cause any major political upheaval in the Earth Alliance.
  • In the Telepath Trilogy of books, Bester is alive, years after the events of Crusade.
  • In “The Road Home” shows Earth still the same as “The Lost Tales” and Stephen Franklin still alive, so it doesn’t contradict anything we knew from “Sleeping In Light”
  • Beyond these examples, I can’t think of any other implications from stories set later in the B5 universe.

A Call to Arms

If anyone reading this has any further information on Crusade Season 2 onwards they know and would like to share it or notice any errors in my information, please comment or get in touch and I’ll happily add it to the discussion here.

So long and thanks for reading.

crusade 13 - exc and b5

< Previous Episode: Little Bugs Have Lesser Bugs | Home: Crusade: What the Hell Happened Next – The Unproduced Episodes >

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E14 – To the Ends of the Earth

   Moby Ship

Format: Unproduced Script

Availability: Was online temporarily on the “Bookface” website in the early 2000s. Was included in the B5 Books Crusade Script books

Written by: J. Michael Straczynski, from outline by J. Michael Straczynski

Planned director: Janet Greek

Grade: A-

Spoilers follow

Episode Synopsis:

While the crew are investigating a ruined civilization, Gideon gets a message from the Apocalypse Box. It tells him that the mysterious ship (referred to in the script as a Shadow Hybrid Vessel) which destroyed his former ship (the EAS Cerberus) has been sighted. Gideon asks and gets confirmation from the Box that it is the same ship.

Gideon recalls the team to the Excalibur and jumps to hyperspace in pursuit, using the coordinates the Box has provided. Gideon then calls his most trusted advisors together to explain what he’s doing and why. He gives them the chance to stop his vendetta if they think it correct. Gideon gives them time to decide as they continue to the coordinates.

When they reconvene, Chambers is the only one to disagree, but at that moment the crew find the debris caused by the Shadow vessel’s destruction of an alien vessel. Upon seeing the scale of destruction and murder, Chambers changes her vote to pursue the attackers.

Amongst the carnage, the crew discover a lone lifepod with an injured alien inside. Eilerson is able to get details of the attack from them: The alien ship was followed from another location and then attacked. The aliens were able to cause some damage to the Shadow vessel – its jump engine are offline.

To catch up with the other ship, Gideon attempts a risky tactic that may end up burning out the jump engines. It pays off when they find the other ship, but the Excalibur’s engines are strained. The vessel attempts to outrun the Excalibur and launches fighters as a delaying tactic. Instead of launching fighters, Gideon decides to simply plough through them, absorbing what damage they can inflict during their limited firing window and concentrate on chasing down the crippled vessel. The Excalibur only sustains light damage and continues pursuit.

Galen confronts Gideon about the source of his information, but Gideon won’t open up. The ship hides in an asteroid belt where they attempt to power down and hide from the Excalibur. The Excalibur attempts to do the same to aid in detection, leaving both ships open to impact damage.

Finally the Shadow Hybrid Vessel has to fire thrusters to avoid a collision. This allows the Excalibur to locate it, and the ships do battle. As the Shadow vessel looks likely to jump to Hyperspace, Gideon uses the main guns to cripple the ship.

(credit to

As the Excalibur moves closer to board the vessel, a short message is sent, then the vessel charges its jump engines to self-destruct. The Excalibur attempts to outrun the blast, hiding from most of it behind a large asteroid. The vessel is almost completely destroyed, the Excalibur crew search the debris but find nothing. A silver half-dollar floats away from the debris.

(credit to

The Excalibur then travels to the coordinates the alien victim provided. En route Max demonstrates the similarities between the vessel and Shadow ships. At the coordinates the crew finds a moon with extensive cratering in one region, with some sign of heavy construction equipment in the debris.

Gideon speculates that the kind of ship they destroyed probably wasn’t a one of a kind, and so maybe he didn’t find the exact ship that destroyed the Cerberus. Gideon’s last observation is that the cratering damage looks similar to that made by the Excalibur’s weapon, and that maybe there’s another ship out there with Excalibur’s technology.

Galen contacts another Technomage, who asks if Gideon knows of the Technomages involvement with Shadow technology. Galen tells him no, but he will in time. Gideon orders the ship’s computer to continually scan the frequency for any further signals and the episode finishes as he lays on his bed, listening to the transmission over and over.

Episode Review:

There are obvious difficulties with reviewing a script in comparison to an actual finished episode. That said, “To the Ends of the Earth” looks like it would likely have been one of the better episodes of Crusade. It reads as though it would have been an exciting, fast-paced episode, with pauses here and there for some diffusing humour and character moments to let the story breath a little.

It’s very much a Gideon-centric episode, revolving around his (somewhat justified) Captain Ahab tendencies regarding the mysterious ship that destroyed the Cerberus. It shows how far he’s willing to go and how much he’s willing to risk for what appears to be answers and justice (or more likely, revenge). At the end it seems he might have gotten some of the revenge part out of his system, but the justice and answers are still quite illusive.

In contrast to how Galen hijacks the ships for his own ends in “The Well of Forever”, Gideon does NOT simply order his crew into the fire. That he takes the time to ensure he’s supported by all in his actions, shows more restraint than usually shown in ‘obsession’ episodes such as this. As the chase progresses he’s shown time and again to recognize the cost of his actions and appear to be weighing them.

This episode would have marked the change from the grey (bellhop) uniforms, backs to the Black ones. That Gideon changes into the black uniform just before all hell breaks loose would have been a great visual touch – seeing him in black, while the rest of the crew surrounding him are still in the grey uniform would have been a subtle nod to his descent into darkness, as well as showing how he’s now separate from the rest of the crew.

Galen, despite previously supporting Gideon’s pursuit of revenge and the truth, seems to get cold feet somewhat. Whether tracking down a vessel that is Shadow related is too close to home, or if it’s after he realizes that Gideon’s source is something very unconventional is not clear. Whether Galen knows Gideon’s source is an Apocalypse Box isn’t stated, but it appears he knows it’s a possibility.

Of the rest of the cast, Max gets a funny line or two, but is just “Mr Smarty Pants” otherwise, except for one scene which drove me crazy, where he describes the Shadow Hybrid’s design to Gideon (see below in the Continuity section for more on that). Matheson gets a few good moments with Galen and tears a subordinate a new hole in a surprising scene. Chambers at first votes against Gideon’s request, but it becomes a moot point upon discovery of the destroyed alien ship, as naturally she votes for vengeance/justice (delete as you see fit) at that point. Whether Gideon would have backed down without this incident, would have been very interesting.  Dureena gets little to do, apart from hang around like a spare part, and even states this at one point.

The silent running/asteroid belt scenes would have been dramatic, but I found it a little annoying. It’s quite the cliché and horribly unscientific – the script even changes its mind between whether it’s a belt or a field. I think most of us know the quantities of asteroids in asteroid belts are incredibly few and far between, and sadly nothing like the scene in The Empire Strikes Back with wildly spinning, colliding space rocks… It’s simply not the kind of stellar feature a large spacecraft could “hide” in. You’d hope the show’s ties to JPL might have produced a more scientific option, but we’ll never know. I realize this allows for a cool scene that plays out like a mix of Das Boot and “The Wrath of Khan” – but being honest, the whole scene of the Excalibur limping away from the engine overload is cribbed straight from “Wrath of Khan.” At least Matheson doesn’t have to go get toasted in the reactor…

Another aspect that bugs me a little is the search for clues after the asteroid battle. They search the debris for answers and find none, does no-one think to go back after those fighters they outpaced and question the occupants?!

You can’t help but notice a few rough edges like these that you would hope would have been smoothed off in drafts or during shooting. Here’s another – Gideon makes the request of his staff about whether to pursue the ship after they’ve already left the planet – It’s pretty much decided by that point!

It should be noted that while this would have been a very effects heavy episode, the script shows that it would have been an almost complete “bottle” episode for the Excalibur crew, bar the scenes in the Shuttle and Thunderbolt.

Had this episode been produced and aired in 1998 (without the audience knowing what we do now,) the conversation between Galen and ‘Dirk’ that hints at a connection between the Shadows and the Technomages would have been a huge revelation, casting intense doubt on Galen and his motives. Don’t forget this was long before the Technomage Trilogy or the unproduced scripts were released, which allowed the Technomage/Shadow connection to become common knowledge amongst fans.

In conclusion, had this script been produced, it would have been a real turning point for the show, basically the “Signs and Portents” for Crusade. As well as being an intense, character developing episode, it would have also widened the scope of the show considerably. It demonstrates that there are human forces at work, either working with a Shadow Servant race (such as the Drakh) or making use of left over Shadow technology. As well as raising serious suspicions over Galen and why he’s there.

 Crusade Continuity:

  • GALENWATCH – Present.
  • Still no Drakh! That’s only 3 of 15 episodes that they appear in.
  • Gideon states the date is September 3rd, 2267.
  • The episode title “To The Ends of the Earth” could have multiple implications in this episode – the most obvious being Gideon scouring the galaxy for revenge. However both the Excalibur and the Hybrid vessel could both be seen to be carrying out the ‘ends’ of Earth (when “ends” is used to mean an “intention” or “goal”) depending on their goals.
  • Apparently “To the Ends of the Earth” was in pre-production when the show got shut down by TNT.
  • They get rid of the grey bellhop uniforms, sort of. Gideon changes into his at the start, but it appears from the script everyone remains in grey until the end of it. The next episode would probably see the entire crew changed over to black.

We see a couple of new features to the Excalibur:

  1. The Excalibur has previously unseen countermeasures. Small crystalline objects that can be ejected to disperse energy beams. The script notes mention the beam would be refracted into various colors as they break down the various frequencies – A nice image.
  2. According to this script, the Excalibur is capable of quickly reaching 0.75% of light speed in normal space, which according to Matheson is their maximum speed. This seems way beyond anything seen in the show for sublight capabilities. However, it must be said the technology capabilities on B5 were always a bit malleable to fit the plot.

Lets be honest, the star of the show would have been the Shadow Hybrid Vessel:

We only ever caught glimpses of it in previous episodes, but here it would have been front and center throughout. There’s plenty we learn from the script:

  1. The Shadow Hybrid is described by Gideon as being “modified” from the ship he saw 8 years earlier (the images above are from “The Path of Sorrows, and so from that time period). The script doesn’t expand on this, so what would that have meant – did the configuration look different? Might there have been more human-looking technology grafted onto it? If it did look that different it’s surprising Gideon is so sure it’s the same ship.
  2. We know the standard Shadow vessels could enter hyperspace at will, with no need for jump points. It’s stated this vessel has jump engines, somehow the aliens were even able to know that’s what they damaged. The ship we see above has no obvious elements to identify technology, just an overall organic appearance.
  3. The script describes the Shadow Hybrid Vessel as “visibly damaged” following the confrontation with the alien vessel. It would have been interesting to see the form that took.
  4. The Shadow Hybrid Vessel has fighters which it launches – would these have been the standard “Shadow Fighters?” Something different but Shadow-based or more Earthlike in technology? No mention is made of the appearance, but had they looked more human, surely it would have been noted by the characters.
  5.  The Shadow Hybrid vessels communication is described as “having an almost melodic but scary quality to the sound” . Sounds almost like Kosh.
  6. Think back on the difference between this hybrid vessel and the EarthForce Omega  Hybrids seen at the end of the Human Civil War. The ship seen in the flashbacks looks like pure Shadow technology, while the Omegas looked like a basic ‘cut and shut’ graft of Shadow upon existing EarthForce technology.

14 - omega

This leads me to what I was threatening to get completely side-tracked with earlier. How ridiculous and annoying the scene with Max is, spelling out the vessel’s similarity to Shadow technology to Gideon. Seriously Max?! We didn’t need your smarts to work that one out. Yes, I understand this odd obfuscation might have been done to somewhat sate the demands of the TNT execs about not tying things to Babylon 5 too explicitly, but it makes no bloody sense and drives me crazy. Sorry to go on, but I will and here’s why:

  1. The scene makes it appear that Max and Gideon know very little about the Shadow War and the Shadows in general. We know Earth wasn’t involved in the Shadow War directly, and Clarke’s administration probably ignored/censored/downplayed the Shadow War as it unfolded, but following Clarke’s fall, the Earth (appears to) become a democracy again. The general population would learn (from the other races, involved humans and surely John Sheriden himself) that while they were kept in the dark a GALACTIC SCALE WAR just took place. Involving almost all the alien races known to humans – and it was orchestrated by the Vorlons and oh, a race called the Shadows. That would be insanely important news, not some forgotten footnote. Are we to believe the best Max has are a few fuzzy images of a Shadow vessel?
  2. Max’s ENTIRE job was going out, finding new technology and helping IPX exploit it – the Shadows are long gone, their tech was of the highest caliber and some of it might have been left behind. It wouldn’t just vaguely be on his radar, it would be an IPX top priority. Well, second to Vorlon tech maybe…
  3. Gideon. It’s hard to know where to start. He’s seen the ship before, it’s burnt into his memory. It never even OCCURRED to me before this script that he didn’t know the vessel was Shadow related – it’s blatantly from a similar technological base as the Shadow Vessels. What this script is asking me to believe is that for the last five plus years he’s SOMEHOW not seen images of an infamous alien race that travel in black, shiny, massively powerful vessels that helped orchestrate the biggest galactic war Earth in recent memory. Mightn’t you think the guy, who’s been shown as obsessional about finding a ship of unknown origins wouldn’t have scoured every possible record? Sorry, rant over.
  • In a nice nod to Babylon 5, Chambers refers to the description of the vessel as “something out of a nightmare” – this is the same as Warren Keffer’s comment about the Shadow vessel he sees.
  • The “half dollar” scene is an obvious hint to the audience that it had humans onboard (the Excalibur’s crew miss it though). Although, as Shadow vessels required a living host and they often had human minions, it could have come from the pocket of one, and not be indicative of a whole crew of humans.
  • It also becomes apparent that Gideon implicitly has Matheson’s support in any attempts to find the ship that destroyed the Cerberus. Matheson seems okay with having to cover for Gideon and even his possession of the Apocalypse box.
  • It’s confirmed in the script (but not stated aloud by anyone) that Matheson knows about the Apocalypse Box, yet Gideon doesn’t know Matheson knows. Why is that? Did he detect it telepathically? Did he read it in Gideon’s mind? Does it sing to him at night? Was Matheson responsible for submitting the design specs for that secret compartment in Gideon’s room? (which is really is goofy when you think about it).

crusade 14 - box3

  • Gideon’s doubts at the end of the episode about the vessel being the exact one, go to show that while the Apocalypse Box told him this, he doesn’t fully believe or trust the box.
  • Gideon and Matheson share a Thunderbolt, I think this is the first time we would have seen two characters interact inside one of the two-person fighters. I think we’ve only ever previously seen the pilots.
  • Eilerson mentions that maybe the Excalibur isn’t the only one out there scouring the galaxy for lost alien technologies… We know! He works for them!

Speculation Central:

  • The main unanswered question revolves around the Shadow Hybrid and the construction site. Who are they? Where did the technology come from? What are their motivations?
  • The Shadow Hybrid is described as “modified” from the ship he saw 8 years earlier  (as seen in The Path of Sorrow), might this mean that the original was a “true” Shadow vessel, operating for the Shadows, while this one was not? Maybe the humans found it, retrofitted it and now use it?
  • The entire “making Dureena feel useless” aspect seems like set-up/foreshadowing to becoming Galen’s apprentice soon – it’s a pointless scene otherwise. She could have at least helped out as a stretcher-bearer!
  • I might be king of the slow people, but seeing Gideon get truly obsessional finally makes sense as to why Gideon would have accepted the Apocalypse Box back when he was a Lieutenant. The box was portrayed as incredibly spooky and dangerous, but he’s so absorbed with finding the ship, that he’ll take any source, no matter how dubious.
  • Along these lines of obsession, it should also be noted Gideon was Captain of an Explorer Class vessel prior to the Excalibur. It could be for a number of reasons, including simply being ordered to, but being in command of a ship exploring the deep unknown would have increased his chances of finding answers out there.
  • Why does the Shadow vessel show up now? The ship has been around for at least 9 years, so I doubt this is it’s first trip out in all that time. That suggests that maybe the Apocalypse Box knew its whereabouts all along and was biding it’s time to tell Gideon for its own reasons. Maybe the Box was hoping to (or did) get something out of engineering this encounter… As the implication is that there could be multiple ships of the same kind, might the Box have made him target this particular one?
  • Which previously unseen alien race did the Shadow vessel attack? Might we see them again and what was the alien vessel doing there?
  • Will Galen attempt to find Gideon’s information source?
  • Will Gideon’s actions result in any noticeable alienation of his crew?

Gideon and Matheson’s discussion about having an “opposite number” out there is interesting, as is the suggestion that the damage was from a weapon like the Excalibur’s main gun. This raises questions:

  1. Is it another “Victory Class” vessel? There was supposedly only two made by the Interstellar Alliance (see “A Call to Arms,”) but that was about nine months ago. Could more have been made secretly by another faction than the IA? Did they get the designs off Drake also?
  2. Maybe it’s just another vessel with the same “main gun” technology. I think the IA adapted Vorlon technology to make it, maybe their “opposite number” has access to Vorlon technology instead.

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

< The Unproduced Episodes Introduction | Next Episode: Value Judgments >

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E15 – Value Judgements

Call Him “Al”

Format: Unproduced Script

Availability: Was online for a very short time on the “Bookface” website in the early 2000s. It is included in the Crusade Script book “Other Voices – Volume 2”

Written by Fiona Avery

Director planned: Mike Vejar

Grade: B

Spoilers follow

Episode Synopsis:

The Excalibur visits Tariff’s Colony, a space station orbiting a moon. The moon has an alien vault structure that Gideon has been told should be investigated to help in finding a cure for the plague. The Governor of the colony has made a deal with IPX for them to study it, but not Earthgov. He demands a fee for access, Gideon counters to play poker for access, the Governor intrigued, accepts.

As an employee of IPX, Eilerson goes ahead and checks out the structure with a number of IPX technicians from the Excalibur. As they are inspecting the door into the structure, some form of defense mechanism activates, incapacitating the two technicians closest to the door.

The injured technicians are evacuated to the Excalibur. Chambers lets Max know that the technicians have both suffered major strokes, she suspects the cause is something like a telepathic mind blast. Matheson looks at the medical data and confirms her suspicions, but notes a lack of a “Psychic Imprint” – meaning a person didn’t cause it. He’s heard rumours that the older races possessed devices that could cause this damage. Matheson wants to go inspect the structure.

Gideon beats the Governor at poker, almost going so far as to accuse him of cheating through telepathy. Gideon tells him to check his records if he doesn’t believe him. The Governor mentions a general distrust of telepaths in the colony and that only one by the name of Al lives there, but outside of the colony.

Gideon tells Matheson to stay on the ship until he’s checked the site personally. There he meets Eilerson and Dureena. Dureena lets them know the physical locks are a dead end and they need Matheson. They are being observed covertly on camera by some local criminals who think the crew are after something valuable.

On arriving, Matheson scans the lock, but his powers aren’t sufficient to open it, they’ll need a stronger telepath and it will take days for them to arrive. Gideon, Chambers, Matheson, Dureena and Eilerson go in search of the local Telepath “Al”. On finding him, they learn that he’s Alfred Bester – former Psi Cop and wanted fugitive.

On learning who he is, they are confronted by Matheson who wants to simply arrest Bester and find another telepath. The others talk to Bester and discuss whether he can help and whether they should cut a deal with him – the greater good after all. Bester offers his help in return for safe passage off the colony, he refers to “bloodhounds” after him, who he believes are closing in. Bester is right, a couple of vessels are on their way to find him, and he learns they are now in the system.

Gideon defers to Matheson’s knowledge of Bester and the threat he causes, when Bester comes out and says he’ll help them, but at a price. In return for safe passage he’ll help them with the alien structure and NOT implicate Matheson as a fictional accomplice in his crimes… The crew grudgingly agree.

Bester is able to open the mechanisms to the alien vault. It’s an empty cave with a small trickle of water running down the wall. They all think it’s a bust, except for Dureena, who points out that the medical benefits they seek may be in a more natural form – the running water and the crystalline build-up around it. As they collect samples of the water and crystals, Eilerson discovers a scroll-container buried in the floor, then the door slowly begins to close. They can’t stop the door, so all leave quickly. Max barely escapes with the scroll container.

As the team leave in the shuttle, they get a call to visit the Governor before leaving with their findings. Upon docking, they are jumped by the local criminals. They’re outnumbered, but after Bester kills one of them with a mind blast who was about to bludgeon Matheson, the criminals turn and run.

Back on board the Excalibur they learn that the substances will act as a potent pain and symptom reliever, potentially extending life spans by up to six months. The beings that left the ‘spring’ guarded had evolved beyond matter, they knew nothing of its origins, but considered it sacred and that any who could open their safeguards would be worthy of taking custody.

Bester is left in a shuttle in hyperspace at coordinates he designates. Gideon suggests that maybe they should destroy it and save everyone the trouble. Matheson considers it, but concludes that summary execution would make them no better than Bester. After the Excalibur leaves, a Psi Corps mothership arrives and collects Bester, it appears the Psi Corps may not have been as thoroughly defeated in the Telepath Crisis as previously thought.

The pilots of the vessels pursuing Bester inform their boss that Bester had vanished, but at about the same time that the Excalibur was there. Their boss is revealed to be Michael Garibaldi.

Episode Review:

Prior to reading it for the first time, I knew the script would feature Bester and so I always assumed the script would be about the crew getting caught up in a game of cat and mouse between Bester and Garibaldi, one where you’re not sure who’s the cat and who’s the mouse… Instead it’s one where Bester tries to justify his actions and helps the crew for his own ends. So it certainly confounded my expectations.

The script seems deceptively simple on first read. It’s well paced, so much so that you’ve read it before you know it. The praise for this has to go to Fiona Avery, her writing of the characters is superb throughout, as she’s shown previously in “The Well of Forever.” Now she also has the infamous Bester to write and she portrays him just as you’d imagine – it’s obvious she had a lot of fun writing him. Every line of dialogue begs to be read with Walter Koenig’s voice and style, so much so you can even image how he would deliver the lines. Take this small excerpt:

GIDEON
That’s all you’re going to say? “It was a war not a crisis… won’t you have some tea?”

BESTER
Yes.
 (beat)
And the tea is getting cold.

You can just imagine Walter Koenig’s slow, dry delivery of the second line.

Praise for the character writing aside, sadly the story is a little basic. Much like “The Well of Forever,” the actual plot is pretty much only there to hang character moments from, but when they’re this good it’s really hard to complain. It’s not a particularly action-oriented episode and despite the injection of an unrequired fistfight with the local cardboard thugs, it becomes quite talky. As the previous episode was probably very high budget due to its effects, this might have been a chance to have a quieter, more introspective (cheaper) episode.

Unsurprisingly, most of the regular crew ends up playing second fiddle to Bester throughout. Surprisingly, Gideon takes a little bit of a back seat to allow Matheson to shine in some great scenes. It also helps demonstrate once more, what Eilerson, Chambers and Dureena all bring to the mission, in terms of their unique skills and knowledge.

Gideon gets to show off his reputation as a gambler yet again. One thing I have to point out: The deal with the Governor sucks – why would the Governor agree to it? When Gideon offers to gamble for the fee, what is in it for the Governor? He now has 50% less chance of getting his fee ! It doesn’t raise the stakes at all – why wasn’t it “double or nothing?” Talking of strange things with the Governor, there’s also a line where it seems the Governor might be hitting on Gideon, it’s either out of left field or just a very weird piece of dialogue, I can’t tell.

The reason they need Bester’s help – the alien vault, disarming its defense mechanisms and the ultimate reveal of what it contains are quite satisfying. While it doesn’t contain a full cure, every little helps and somewhat dilutes the bad taste left in everyone’s mouths from having to make a deal with Bester. The moment where Eilerson escapes by the skin of his teeth might be an Indiana Jones rip-off, but it would have been fun to watch.

My biggest problem with the script is that it touches on some very deep subjects, but never does them full justice. For example:

  • We hear Bester protest his innocence or at least try to explain to Matheson that he only did what he had to for his people, that history is judged by the victors and that he’s the hero of his own story. You even have Dureena playing devil’s advocate by saying, quite correctly, that rumours, accusations and gut feelings are not a proof of guilt. This isn’t a new approach for villains and was how Babylon 5 always approached Bester (see “Ship of Tears” specifically). If the script had left it there, you’d be forced to judge Bester in shades of grey by the end of the episode, giving the audience something interesting to mull over. Instead he’s picked up by a secret Psi Corp mothership, then remarks “the remaining few death wagons are in good hands.” This ruins the argument he makes earlier, as we all know only the bad guys are going to have “Death Wagons.” It’s almost like the excellent Mitchell and Webb sketch about the SS:

you-are-the-bad-guy-but-this-doesn-amp-039-t-mean-that-you-amp-039-re-a-bad-guy_o_5061151

  • That he then goes on to utter vague threats of coming retribution, puts him squarely back in the “evil psychotic mastermind” category and easier to dismiss as just a villain.
  • The other area I would have liked to see expanded is when Bester states that telepaths and humans are “no longer the same beast” – this could have lead to an interesting examination of how some telepaths develop their superiority complex, especially if they begin to perceive ‘normal’ humans as lesser beasts. After all, with Bester,  he’s the epitome of how “putting your own people first” is often at the expense of everyone else – if he sees “normals” as little more than cattle, he feels fully justified. This could even have led to Matheson questioning his argument, himself and his comrades, but sadly, it’s not explored.
  • I’ll admit this is now going into the realm of nitpicking, but the biggest “first draft flaw” to the script, and would hopefully have been fixed in later drafts, is the location they visit. Early on we’re told in the script that Tarriff’s Colony is a space station floating above a desolate moon, one which is mined for water. The Governor states that “Al lives outside of town” – sorry, which town is that? To add to that, when the crew go search for “Al” it’s specified in the script that this is back on board the space station, Gideon even states they have to go back to the station to find him! Additionally, the thugs are described as being on the space station, yet they say the “Earthforce Pigs are at a dig outside of town,” but are waiting in the space station’s cargo hold to confront them after they return from the vault. You have to assume that originally it was written as a surface colony, then changed to a space station for some reason and things were left in the script by mistake.

Here’s a horrible thought to leave you with: The evolved alien race who secured the spring, did so that only those who they considered evolved enough could gain access and become its new guardians. That means that of everyone there, only Bester is “evolved” enough…

Crusade Continuity

  • Galenwatch – Absent
  • Still no Drakh! That’s only 3 of 16 episodes so far (if you include A Call to Arms) that they appear in.
  • We finally learn that Matheson has a telepath rating of P6, which makes him a medium level ability telepath (Bester is P12, Lyta Alexander and Talia Winters were both P5s before their upgrades).
  • There is no mention in the script, but you have to assume the whole crew are back in black uniforms from the last episode.
  • The alien vault was found by chance during ice mining being carried out.
  • The contents of the vault aren’t exactly exceptional in their abilities. Yes it has great painkilling and symptom-easing power, but we’re not talking a fountain of youth, immortality or even a cure-all. It seems like overkill for the defensive systems and the alien’s description. Add to that, the super-evolved aliens left the details on a scroll. Yes, a scroll. I know, I know, maybe it wasn’t paper, but some kind of super advanced, space papyrus they left on the floor…
  • A shuttle pilot is featured, but only has one line. Maybe this could have been the illusive Trace Miller…
  • The space station “Tariff’s Colony” is described as “Babylon 5 walls and dressing; similar space station. Earth built” and Al’s quarters being in an area similar to Babylon 5’s Down Below.
  • In the flashback/voiceover, Bester gets referred to as being “Meta Pol.” I’m 99.9% sure I’ve never heard that term before. So is the term “Psi Cop” more like slang? As far as I know that’s never been implied before. I’d have to assume “Meta Pol” is a truncating of something like “Metasensory Police”.
  • Bester calls Matheson “Lieutenant” at one point. Is this simply a reference to rank, meant as an insult or simple surprise that he’s joined EarthForce?
  • When Bester and Matheson discuss the Psi Corps, Matheson states that “On the Excalibur, I don’t have to prove my loyalty. With the Corps, my loyalty was always tested. Always questioned. The Corps was so paranoid.” While that may be true of Earthforce, they’re still happy to have him invasively deep-scanned for the privilege of joining up, every six months (see “The Well of Forever”).
  • The “Dark Ships” that Garibaldi’s bloodhounds use are described as looking like an “Earth design, but sleek and silent – like a 2267 equivalent of a Stealth Bomber.” – There is a Tim Earls design in the B5@20 book, where they seem to have something of a flattened delta appearance (quite like a Stealth Bomber). That said, they can’t be that stealthy if Bester gets an early warning.

Telepath / Non-Telepath Terminology:

This episode, more than any other in Crusade, focuses on telepaths, but the terminology used by telepathic and non-telepathic humans remains as inconsistent as it tended to be on Babylon 5:

  • Telepath = Seems to be the scientific, accurate description for telepaths used by both peoples
  • Teep = More of a slang term for telepath. While it could possibly be used by non-telepaths as derogatory, Bester uses it to refer to his people in normal conversation. Whether it was once derogatory and has been ‘reclaimed’ by telepaths isn’t clear.
  • Blip or Rogue =  Telepaths avoiding joining Psi Corps or taking the  ability-suppressing drugs.
  • Normal = A term for non-telepaths. Used by both telepaths and non-telepaths, but it could be considered something of a loaded term. When used by humans about themselves it could imply the telepaths aren’t ‘normal’ or are, in fact, ‘abnormal.’ While it tends to be what most telepaths refer to non-telepaths to their face, it somewhat implies the humans are ‘normal’ and the telepaths are ‘special’.
  • Mundane = A derogatory term used by telepaths for non-telepaths and one that would tend to be seen as rude by non-telepaths seeing as the typical definition of mundane is “common; ordinary; banal; unimaginative.” This makes Matheson’s use of it twice to non-telepaths to describe them, a bit strange. I’m pretty sure he hasn’t used it before this episode. The Well of Forever script seemed careful to use the word “normal”, instead of “mundane” throughout.

Speculation Central

  • When we hear the voiceover of “Bester’s trial” it’s not immediately clear whether this is how Bester imagines one would occur, or if it’s an actual flashback and Bester escaped after. The audio is described as “voiceover/flashback” but I’m still not convinced this actually happened.
  • We’ve learnt from interviews that in later seasons the Excalibur’s crew would end up on the run from Earthforce due to false charges, might this mean that they would also be on the run from Mr. Garibaldi, as he would blame them for Bester’s escape?
  • It’s never made clear how Bester is warned. The device that warns him is described as a “pocket-com” with the warning message “Warning, pursuit team on route, sighted in this sector” – who or what is watching for his pursuers? How do they get noticed in their stealth ships?
  • In addition, how does the Psi Corps mothership know when and where to pick him up? It doesn’t seem like they were the ones watching out for Bester’s safety as their conversation shows they’ve not spoken for three years.
  • Those guys sent to catch Bester would be highly susceptible to attack or suggestion seeing as Bester is a P12. Might this suggest they are also P12s or maybe have some kind of (previously unseen) psychic-blocking technology? It’s only implied from the situation that they are human, the script doesn’t specify, I’m not sure if certain races are immune to psychics of other races.
  • If the medical benefits they find in the vault are equally applicable to Dureena’s people, an extra six months would be huge for them (50% longer life expectancy!) and her. It’s surprising it’s not mentioned.
  • I’m not sure if we were supposed to see any more of Bester in Crusade, but any further appearances would have been greatly appreciated.
  • It should be pointed out that Dureena overlooking Bester’s accusations allows for a quicker resolution of the immediate access issue, and that her own people have a lot less time left than the humans. I don’t think that’s the impression we’re supposed to take from her attitude, but it could be seen that way.

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

< Previous Episode: To the Ends of the Earth | Next Episode: Darkness of the Soul >

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E16 – Darkness of the Soul

   What’s in the Box?

Grade: N/A

Format: Unwritten Script

Availability: Unavailable

Planned writer: J. Michael Straczynski

Planned director: John Copeland

Spoilers follow

Episode Synopsis

There is next to nothing about this episode beyond it’s name. All that I could find about it are from the Crusade script book Other Voices: Volume 2

  • “‘Darkness of the Soul’ (117) – possibly the story in which Galen would have discovered Gideon’s Apocalypse Box” – Jason Davis, editor of Crusade: Other Voices Volume 2. I don’t know where he got the idea of the content of the episode from – whether from JMS himself, the “JMS archives” (aka: the JMS storage unit) or just reasonable speculation.
  • Max Eilerson was scheduled to appear.
  • Planned director: John Copeland

Really, this is it, the sum total of information I could find.

Episode Review

Not applicable

Crusade Continuity

  • The script was about to be written by Joe Straczynski, when they received word that TNT was cancelling Crusade.
  • Galenwatch – I would have to assume he’d be here
  • No idea if the Drakh would turn up or not
  • Date unknown

Speculation Central

This is a game of joining the dots between the events of “Value Judgments” and “Tried and True,” “The Sword Trilogy” and “End of the Line”

I have to admit this is me really going to town now on the tiniest of evidence. If the one-line synopsis is to be believed, you’d assume the following:

  • Galen appears
  • Gideon also appears, he has the Box after all
  • Somehow Galen discovers the Apocalypse Box
  • I’d guess that after learning of it, he’d tear Gideon a new one for using it
  • Whether Galen would also know/discover Matheson knew about it and kept it secret also is hard to know – if he did, it would allow Gideon to find out Matheson knew of its existence also?
  • Would we finally learn how Matheson knew it existed?
  • While it’s possible Galen knows some of the story of the Apocalypse Boxes, Max might also have information on it to share, given his background. If he knew it was onboard he’d have to be itching to see it.
  • Would we have gotten definitive proof of what the box is and what it contains, or just more rumours from Galen?

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

< Previous Episode: Value Judgments | Next Episode: Tried and True >

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E17 – Tried and True

A Room for Two

Grade: C-

Format: Unproduced Draft Script

Availability: Included in the Crusade Script book “Other Voices – Volume 2”

Written by Fiona Avery

Director planned: Sandy Smolan

Spoilers follow

Episode Synopsis

Dureena is summoned by her old Thieves’ Guild mentor Mafeek of Tripani 7. Dureena travels to the old, dilapidated space station where he’s set up his base of operations.

As she arrives, it appears Mafeek is in the middle of assisting a client – he seems to be trying to assuage a new client’s fears about the abilities of the Thieves’ Guild and a plan they’ve set in motion. He finishes his conversation before talking with Dureena.

At first they exchange pleasantries and catch up a little, but it becomes clear quickly to Dureena that she’s been summoned for more than reminiscences. They discuss the Excalibur and Mafeek asks her to return to work with him.

He wants to know why she left, was she upset about him taking a new apprentice, or was her need for revenge on the Drakh above making profit?

Then a second client calls and wants assistance, he has a White Star causing him problems. Mafeek says he’ll send backup.

They continue talking and discuss whether she’s using the crew, or that they’re using her. Dureena concludes that everyone uses each other in the universe.

Mafeek wants to know who she’s loyal to, is she loyal to him? He reminds her that he fought to free her from the fighting pits, before training her as a thief. He doesn’t want her to throw away all the potential he saw in her. She tells Mafeek, that everything she’s seen and done with the Excalibur crew has only made her skills better. Mafeek implies her trust in the crew is a mistake.

The first client calls again, now he’s in trouble and needs help from Mafeek.

Dureena has had enough of Mafeek’s games and doesn’t want to distract him from his obviously busy work. She goes to leave the room and can’t. She’s locked in. Mafeek says it’s because he has reason to believe she’ll give Guild secrets to the Interstellar Alliance or Earthforce and she can’t leave until he can trust her.

To begin with, he mentions that her membership of the Guild was exposed to Sheridan, and now he has that knowledge, he has the potential to exploit it, and that’s a big threat to the guild.

Mafeek goes on to ask why she’s there on the Excalibur. Dureena says she’s become her own person. Not longer just a slave, a student or a guild member. Simply Dureena. The crew respects her and she’s never been truly respected.

Again, the second client calls. The Guild backup has arrived. Dureena asks for mercy for the Ranger pilot and complains about Mafeek’s actions, but does not stop them. The back-up vessel destroys the White Star. She notes the Guild have access to powerful Centauri weapons.

Again Mafeek wants to know who she’s loyal to. He offers her a high position in the Guild in return for intel on the Excalibur, it’s crew, the Interstellar Alliance and Earthforce. She rejects his offer saying both the Guild and him are angry she left them, but she has a responsibility for the Excalibur and it’s crew.

Mafeek wants to know about her loyalty to the Guild. Dureena replies that she has none, as she’s resigning. He says the Guild will put a price on her head if she leaves. Dureena says that it’s better that than having her loyalty constantly questioned. Mafeek will have to trust her.

The first client calls, his backup also arrived and it all worked out.

Finally Mafeek smiles and says she has no reason to leave the guild, as he’s convinced of her loyalty and she’s free to go. He tells Dureena he chose to judge her as he knows and understands her. Other’s wouldn’t have been so easy on her.

He said he tried using guilt, threats and bribes to see who she’s loyal to and how much her word is actually worth, as it appears to be worth a great deal, he knows he can trust her promise.

As Dureena leaves, Mafeek tells her he’s glad she’s grown out of her anger, she realizes that maybe she has.

Episode Review

Before any review I have to acknowledge that this is the first draft of a script and as such it’s an attempt to get from point A to point B, while trying to trying to tell the basic story the author had in mind. Doing this while still making sense can be pretty difficult, so judging this early draft in the same manner as a full script must allow a lot of leeway.

According to the Crusade script book “Other Voices Volume 2” this draft was written at the last moment as a replacement for Peter Woodward’s script “Little Bugs have Lesser Bugs” which was bumped to season 2 for unknown reasons. This means that this script was almost definitely written very quickly.

While I think the idea of Dureena being trapped in a room and basically being put on trial is an interesting and possibly intense idea for a story, this script doesn’t really pull it off well enough in my opinion. While there is plenty of snappy back and forth, it feels like the questions go around in circles too often, making it hard to keep track of, so much so that you begin to stop caring what Mafeek is looking for from Dureena. Comparing this episode with similar ones such as “Intersections in Real Time” or “Comes the Inquisitor”, it feels more lightweight.

Having two clients interrupt their discussion, both requiring assistance from Mafeek’s comrades is too much. It makes Mafeek seem like a busy, important guy, but it’s needless duplication – the one with the Ranger would prove Dureena will still keep their secrets, the other is irrelevant.

Not to dig too deep, but this is a Thieves guild, not a crime syndicate. There is no sneaking or artistry here, just a lot of murdering. Odd for a bunch of people who should be picking pockets and burglarising homes. This group act more like cheap thugs.

Of course, it’s an early draft and would have been improved in many ways, but sadly we never get to see a later draft, as a few days after this was submitted, TNT pulled the plug on Crusade. It would have provided a nice showcase for Carrie Dobro’s talents, an actress who really deserves more work.

Crusade Continuity

  • Galenwatch – Absent in this draft
  • Still no Drakh – That’s only 3 of 18 episodes (if you include A Call to Arms) that they appear in.
  • No date mentioned.
  • The station is not named, nor the location.
  • We know Dureena was sold into slavery, she then ended up in the ‘fighting pits’ of Talos 29 – where she got her fighting skills, before becoming a thief. This might  imply she wasn’t a ‘good’ slave and that was the reason why she ended up in the fighting pits.
  • Mafeek is described in the script as a similar looking race to Dureena’s, but more demonic-looking. Are the races related?
  • The back-up vessels that destroy the White Star are described as Raider vessels, but bigger and better equipped, with Centauri weaponry.

Speculation Central

  • How does Dureena get there? Apparently the Excalibur is in the area, but we don’t know if she was dropped off, flew herself, or came with a group.
  • The script never mentions who the clients or contact are, might they have used an interesting guest star for the voices?
  • The “Other Voices Volume 2” book mentioned that JMS believed that Fiona Avery had plans to ‘open up the script’ to include other locations and characters.
  • You’ll have to forgive me for digressing here and feel free to skip on if you don’t want to read fanfic, but The Babylon 5 podcast folks mentioned they’d have liked to see Galen be part of a subplot where he’s tracking down Dureena. I agree, it would have been a cool idea:
    • Intercut between the Dureena scenes by having Galen learn of the threat against her (somehow), then moving heaven and earth to find her. You’d see him operating with Technomage skills at full 100%;  tracking her movement, solving clues, hacking systems, cracking locks, beating thugs, finally he reaches the station, he’s rushing towards Mafeek’s quarters, when Dureena simply walks out. She turns, shakes Mafeek’s hand and Galen is left dumbfounded. Dureena is more than capable of rescuing herself.
    • Mafeek (looking Galen up and down): Is that “magician” out there with you Dureena?
    • Dureena: Hmm. He can never make his mind up about that.
    • Mafeek: Well, take him with you, and tell him to stop hitting my employees.
    • Galen: Uhhhhh, Dureena?
    • Galen doesn’t quite know what to do next. Dureena pushes him in front of her down the corridor. Galen glances behind them.
    • Dureena: Come on. My hero.
  • Would we ever have seen Mafeek, his apprentice or the Thieves’ Guild if the series had progressed?

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

< Previous Episode: Darkness of the Soul | Next Episode: Untitled (Episode 18) >

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E18 – Untitled

   Who knows!

Grade: N/A

Format: Unwritten Script

Availability: Unavailable

Planned writer: J. Michael Straczynski

Planned director: J. Michael Straczynski

Spoilers follow

Episode Synopsis

There is next to nothing known about this episode: “Episode would have involved the discovery of a construction base. Only exists as a one line description.” Crusade script book Other Voices: Volume 2.

Really, this is it, the sum total of information I could find. The script was still to be written by Joe Straczynski, when they received word that TNT was cancelling Crusade.

Episode Review

Not applicable

Crusade Continuity

  • Galenwatch – No idea
  • No idea if the Drakh would turn up or not
  • Date unknown

Speculation Central

So “the discovery of a construction base.” That leaves almost nothing to go on – you’d have to imagine it would likely have something to do with either of the main plots – the Drakh plague or the Earthforce/Shadow conspiracy. That’s all folks.

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

< Previous Episode: Tried and True | Next Episode: War Story (Sword Trilogy 1) >

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E19 – War Story (Sword Trilogy Part 1)

Pound some Ground

Grade: B-

Format: Outline and Unsanctioned Script

Availability: Included in the Crusade Script book, Other Voices Volume 2

Written by Richard Mueller

Planned director: Jeff Woolnough

Spoilers follow.

Episode Synopsis

A planet is discovered that has minerals that may help in treating the Drakh Plague. The Excalibur and a detachment of Marines is sent to protect a mining expedition from the suspected Drakh interference.

Detailed Episode Synopsis

When a survey vessel finds a “Rare Earth” (Ditillium) vital to treatment of the Drakh Plague on a world known as Savo Four, Earthforce sends two Omega Class ships to scout the area more. On arrival, the Hector and Romulus detect a high energy transmission, two hours later an overwhelming Drakh force arrives and destroys them.

In orbit around Mars, General Thompson tasks Gideon with finding out what has happened to the two missing vessels. In addition he is to escort a space liner (the Chaumont) with 200 Martian miners sent to retrieve the elements. To assist in the matter, a company of Marines will be sent on board the Excalibur. Gideon places Matheson in charge of any ground operations that may occur at Savo Four.

En route, Dureena begins to anticipate the possible conflict with the Drakh to come, mentally preparing herself for her first hand to hand combat with the Drakh. During this time Dureena ends up in a brawl with a few Marines after one calls her “girl”, but after beating up some of them, they develop a mutual respect.

Before the Excalibur and the Chaumont are due to drop out of hyperspace, they pick up signals from two “dead men’s beacons.” They prepare for trouble. In orbit they find the debris from the two destroyed Earthforce vessels, then they intercept a high energy transmission, just as the Earth Force destroyers did. Assuming it’s an alarm they launch fighters and take defensive positions as Matheson, Dureena and the Marines land on the surface to investigate what transmitted the signal.

The team lands near wreckage of one of the Omega Destroyers, which is also near the point of origin of the signal. They find and destroy the transmitter with Dureena’s help. They determine the transmitter is clearly of Drakh origin. At this moment, jump points form and six Drakh ships emerge, but the Excalibur is ready.

The Excalibur shields the defenseless Chaumont while it’s secondary guns and fighters engage the Drakh cruisers. Two are taken out quickly. One veers off to engage the ground team, while the remaining three try to target the Chaumont. The ground position is strafed, causing casualties, but the team are able to shoot down the vessel with missile launchers – the team then approach the downed vessel to quell any resistance.

At this point in the battle a huge vessel appears. It’s a white, moon-sized disc that appears to rise over the edge of the planet. The remaining Drakh vessels retreat. Gideon considers firing the main weapon depending on the new arrival’s intent.

On the surface the area is bathed in a harsh white light centering on Dureena. Dureena looks up, brandishing her knife and challenging the vessel. The light flares and Dureena is gone, so is the vessel.

Having no ship to pursue and no way of knowing where it went, the Excalibur remains as the miners set up operations, the injured are tended to and the dead mourned. Gideon asks Matheson if he could sense anything from the white vessel, and while he tried, he was unable to sense anything. Gideon makes a prediction “Once discovered, nothing is able to hide for long”

Review

First up, this script is based on an outline written by Richard Mueller, and while the outline is a lot more basic, almost everything in that outline can be seen in this script. The outline had been considered “generally favorable” by JMS, according to an interview with Richard Mueller, but whether JMS wanted any changes to the general story at that point isn’t known.

At that exact moment, is when Crusade’s cancellation was announced. Richard Mueller then took it upon himself to write the script as an unpaid “audition piece” so many aspects of what is in the outline, may have not made it to the script stage, had JMS given notes on the story. For the most part I’ll treat the review as though it is a fully authorized first draft of a script, as it certainly feels like one.

This is Richard Mueller’s first script for the Babylon 5 universe, but it’s obvious that he knows the universe very well. For a episode called “War Story” it certainly lives up to it’s name. For the most part it’s a fast-paced, thrilling episode. This would have resulted in a particularly effects heavy episode.

While nothing especially deep for most of the characters, we see a lot of Dureena. Her bloodlust and obsession with the Drakh don’t seem to gel with the end of the earlier episode “Tried and True” – where Mafeek compliments her on having moved past her hatred. This seems like a backward step for her character as she obsesses over killing Drakh.

Richard Mueller appears to know the military well (being ex-military himself apparently), and the dialogue appears to show this from the jargon used. These Marines seem to follow a similar outlook and organization as the US Marines. However, this brings up one of the primary problems in the script – obvious comparisons to the Babylon 5 episode “GROPOS.” That episode followed the story of Marines being billeted on Babylon 5 – they rub up against the locals, tempers flare, fights break out, respect is earned, comradeship begins, and sadly soldiers are sometimes killed in action. All those beats are repeated here.

The biggest issue for me though is the plot itself. The script states that a survey ship found the Ditillium and let Earthforce know – how did they not set off the Drakh beacon that time? Then Earthforce sends two Omega class warships (not Warlocks, but still top of the line in Earthforce technology only five years previously) to scout the area and then Earthforce hears nothing back. Why on earth would anyone consider sending an unarmed liner full of civilians to a location which may have enough of an enemy presence to take out TWO warships without leaving a trace? Fine, I could imagine sending the Excalibur in to investigate (especially with Gideon not being a favourite of the top brass), but not sending a big, slow bull’s-eye along with them. I’m no military tactician, but even I’ve heard of securing an area first… I know, it’s a first draft and the plot would be polished to make sense more.

The ending with the White Ship scooping up Dureena could have been either an extremely cool or extremely cheesy moment, depending on how it was shot. It also feels like a very “Star Trek” moment for a Babylon 5 related production.

Crusade Continuity

  • GALENWATCH – Absent
  • Finally some more Drakh! That’s only 4 of 19 episodes (if you include A Call to Arms) that they appear in!
  • The date doesn’t appear to be mentioned at any point

Apparently a new Rare Earth element has been discovered and goes by the name of Ditillium. Hmm, seems a little similar to the name of Babylon 5 writer Larry Ditillio…

The “transmission before ambush” aspect of the Drakh tactics are very reminiscent of their tactics in “A Call to Arms”

Potentially one of the coolest aspects of the episode is the new white vessel. We learn very little from the script, beyond it being:

  • A white, moon-sized disc (Richard Mueller seems to think the design was given by JMS)
  • Had an energy spike the size of a small star
  • Matheson could get no telepathic reading from it
  • It was able to remove Dureena from the planet very quickly. The script outline mentions her being “tractored” off the surface, but this term is not used in the script. While the Minbari ships have exhibited a technology similar to it, it would be the first time that very Star Trek-like definition would have been used.
  • It has engines that allowed it to leave in a manner that seemed almost instantaneous, and did not allow the Excalibur to track or follow.

The surprise appearance of a mysterious “ship of lights” reminds me very strongly of the otherworldly and angelic “Seraphs” in the original Battlestar Galactica – although their vessel was more crystalline than disc-shaped.

The wreckage of one of the Omega class warships just happens to be within walking distance of the Drakh transmitter – that’s either a mighty big convenience or a mighty small planet.

Calkilona is a form of stimulant Dureena’s people have used for centuries. It would be used prior to going into battle. Confusingly, Dr. Chambers mentioned they have no medical records on Dureena’s race, but somehow they have one of their drugs readily available?

Omega Class Destroyers have a device referred to as a “Dead Man’s Beacon” that begins broadcasting once the vessel is destroyed. Whether other Earthforce Vessels have them is not stated. Why the Drakh would not have destroyed those beacons is not stated.

Early plans were to have Christy Marx write the second part and Walter Koenig the third. This changed to become Larry Ditillio writing the second and JMS the third. The reasons why are not stated.

Speculation Central

  • The Drakh turn tail and run immediately after the White Ship appears. This might suggest they have had prior dealings. Or maybe they simply felt threatened by a moon-sized vessel appearing from nowhere.
  • Matheson could get no telepathic readings from the vessel. Could the ship be blocking him? Is it automated? Are the inhabitants blocking him? Could they be so alien he can’t even register them?
  • Why did the White Ship scoop up Dureena? Was it because she was fighting the Drakh? Her defiance in the face of overwhelming power (Matheson takes cover when the ship appears)? A bit of both?

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

< Previous Episode: Untitled (Episode 18) | Next Episode: The Walls of Hell (Sword Trilogy 2) >

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E20 – The Walls of Hell (Sword Trilogy Part 2)

Matheson Meltdown

Grade: N/A

Format: Unfinished Partial Outline

Availability: Included in the Crusade Script book, Other Voices Volume 2

Written by: Larry DiTillio

Planned director: Goran Gajic

Spoilers follow

Episode Synopsis

Gideon makes a deal with the Apocalypse Box to help find Dureena. In doing so, the Box takes over Matheson and then the Excalibur. The Apocalypse Box takes them all down a dark and dangerous path.

Detailed Episode Synopsis

Following on from the previous episode, Gideon and Matheson struggle to think of any way to locate the abducted Dureena. Without Galen onboard, Gideon takes his only option and consults the Apocalypse Box. The Box considers Dureena of no importance, but Gideon does. The Box asks Gideon to bring Matheson, so it can speak to him alone.

From outside the room, Gideon hears a blood curdling scream and rushes in to see Matheson staring wide-eyed at the Box. Matheson says he knows what to do and leaves for the bridge, Gideon follows as the Box laughs in the empty room.

On reaching the ship’s bridge, Matheson’s mind somehow merges with the ship’s systems. He locks the crew from their stations and tells them to leave, as their thoughts are distracting him. Gideon protests, but Matheson reminds him that consulting the Box was his idea and to trust him, but that he needs the Captain to leave the bridge also.

Gideon monitors the situation on the bridge from a security station with the ship’s telepathy specialist who tells the Captain that they believe that the link will put immense stress on Matheson and may result in disability or death. Gideon tells Matheson of this, but is ignored.

Matheson sets course to an uncharted sector and Gideon decides it has all gone far enough. He orders a squad to breach the bridge to arrest Matheson, at which point Matheson’s voice is heard through the ship stating that Matheson and the Excalibur are now one, and that they are taking the ship to a place of power. Gideon orders the assault.

Matheson appears to be fused to the systems with some kind of energy. Matheson jumps them all to hyperspace, but something is different, it’s a variant of hyperspace: “dark space”. Shocked by this turn of events Matheson breaks contact with the ship, and as the security team breaches the door, Matheson is shocked by the influx of new thoughts.

Gideon moves to the helm to try and stop what is happening, Matheson makes a gesture and Gideon suddenly finds himself elsewhere. Suddenly Gideon is in a room with a card table, and he recognizes the place from his past. His friend is tied up and he will have to gamble for his life.

On the bridge Matheson looks around in shock. The security team is somehow encased in the walls. Matheson’s parents appear from nowhere, horrified by his actions, asking him “what has he you done?”.

***

This is the end of the outline. JMS asked Larry DiTillio to wait at this point before continuing further, the series was cancelled shortly after.

Outline Review

It’s basically impossible to rate an episode when it’s only half an outline (hence the “N/A” grade), but it appears Larry DiTillio was trying his best to do something interesting with a very limited cast and options. The only members of the ensemble cast would have been Gideon and Matheson for contract reasons, so it had to be written around them.

Larry DiTillio was interviewed later (info taken from the B5 Wikia) about where he saw the rest of the episode going, and he stated that the episode would have continued with surreal events from Gideon and Matheson’s pasts. The card game resulted in Gideon saving his friend’s life, but condemning another innocent player to death. Matheson’s would have revolved around his telepathy hurting someone as a child and how this resulted in Matheson’s relationship with his parents disintegrating as they grew to fear him.

Larry believed one of the reasons JMS wanted him to wait was to see if they could get Peter Woodward to star in one further episode, so then he might have needed to integrate him into the story.

According to DiTillio the overall theme of the episode would have been that “everything we do has consequence.”

Crusade Continuity

  • GALENWATCH – Maybe, maybe not.
  • No Drakh. Still only up to 4 appearances in 20 episodes.
  • Date unknown
  • A note on the Babylon 5 wikia entry for this episode states that Trace might have also appeared. That is until TNT decided they no longer wanted him, but it does not state where that information came from.
  • Now, in addition to “normal” space, Hyperspace and Thirdspace, “Quantum Space” (mentioned in the Lost Tales, but not much is known beyond it allows travel at twice the speed of Hyperspace), you can now add “Dark Space.” It gives the appearance of extremely slow movement, in addition the region they were traversing was suffering from some kind of electrical storm. Whether this “Space” is completely separate from the others or a subsection of hyperspace isn’t well explained. A note on the Babylon 5 wikia entry for this episode states that “Dark Space” is a “strange region of Hyperspace left over by the Shadows” but does not state where that information came from.
  • The Excalibur apparently has a “Telepathy Specialist” onboard. Is this another telepath? a civilian researcher?

Speculation Central

  • You have to assume that the end point of the episode either led up to them finding the White Ship, or discovering some way of being able to locate and track it,

    to set up for the next episode.

  • Is the Box in full control of Matheson – either remotely or hitching a ride?
  • Are the hallucinations caused by the Apocalypse Box, “Dark Space” or a combination of the two? We know that the hyperspace environment boosts telepathic ability if not shielded by a ship’s infrastructure.
  • Is the Box’s actual reason for the trip through “Dark Space” to cause these effects on Matheson and Gideon? If so, is it simply toying with them or trying to get something out of them by causing the flashbacks? Is it probing their memory possibly?
  • How do the guards get embedded into the wall? Is this Matheson’s new power?
  • Might the Apocalypse Box have a link of some kind with the Shadows, seeing as they were responsible for “dark space”?
  • Does Gideon vanish from the bridge once his visions begin? It might be weird to have Gideon talking to himself while Matheson’s parents berate him on the bridge.
  • What does Matheson think about keeping the Box onboard and Gideon’s having kept it’s existence from him. What does he think should be done with it?
  • What might the lasting effects be on Matheson, does it effect him or his powers? Might he now be an agent (unwitting or otherwise) for the Apocalypse Box?

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

< Previous Episode: War Story (Sword Trilogy Part 1)| Next Episode: Untitled (Sword Trilogy Part 3) >

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E21 – Untitled (Sword Trilogy Part 3)

      And My Sword!

   Format: A few notes and extrapolation from events in the subsequent episode

   Availability: Discussed in the Crusade Script book, “Other Voices Volume 2”

   To be Written by J Michael Straczynski

To be Directed by Mike Vejar

Grade: N/A

Spoilers follow

Episode Synopsis

Dureena returns to the Excalibur after being abducted by the White Ship, with both a new weapon and powerful implants.

Detailed Episode Synopsis

It’s very hard to give a more detailed synopsis when so little is know about what would have taken place in this episode. The only stated information at the moment seems to be:

From the Crusade “Other Voices 2” Jason Davis says notes were found on the story that: “Dureena returns with sword” and the episode “would have set up forbidden tech.” Additionally Dureena is supposed to have no memory of how she got it and the implants – supposedly this is straight from JMS on the Racing the Night commentary. I’ve not got access to the DVD to double check that right now – this is mentioned on the B5 wiki episode page – please feel to chime in with more details. So, not very much to go on.

Per the notes in “Other Voices Volume 2” the alien implants would have “imbued Dureena a number of unexplainable powers.” These notes also describe the implants as being similar to those of the Shadows and Technomages. The notes go on to conclude that maybe Dureena took the opportunity to investigate alternatives to the tutelage Galen had denied her earlier in the season. This last part may just be the writer’s guesswork, as it doesn’t appear to come directly from JMS. For all we know, she was modified without her knowledge or consent. While Galen wasn’t willing to share Technomage secrets with Dureena, it always seemed to be implied that he wouldn’t share them yet.

From the script of the next episode (“To the End of the Line,”) Dureena is apparently safe and unharmed onboard the Excalibur. She has the sword “stowed” (this is how it’s phrased in the script, not hidden) in her quarters. It should also be noted that all the regular crew are present onboard the Excalibur and that it appears to be operating well enough, so it can’t have been too damaged by Matheson’s/The Apocalypse Box’s take over in “The Walls of Hell” or what it took to ensure Dureena’s return in this episode.

Review

It’s pointless to review an episode that doesn’t exist in any format.

Crusade Continuity

  • GALENWATCH – No idea, although him being absent would make little sense seeing as her technology appears so Technomage-like. On top of that, the producers were trying to get him to appear in “The Walls of Hell”. If he had been in part two, it would make sense he would appear in part three.
  • Whether the Drakh would reappear is unknown, although it’s unlikely, as they  turned tail and ran from the White Ship.
  • Date Unknown

Speculation Central

I’ve not got much else to write about, so I’m going to speculate like crazy here:

  • Dureena returns with a magical sword and without any memory of what happened to her (supposedly stated by JMS on the Racing the Night commentary.) So would we have ever seen her time on board the White Ship – either in these episodes or future flashbacks?
  • Why was Dureena taken? Was it because she was fighting both the Drakh (like the rest of the crew), but then also showed determination/defiance in the face of the White Ship’s apparently overwhelming power? Might this have made her “worthy?”
  • Dureena seems to be moving from being a Rogue/Thief character, to maybe more of an Arcane Trickster (to borrow some DND-isms). Galen is clearly a Warlock.

The Sword:

  • Is the sword literally the same one shown in the title credits? It would be a lost opportunity if it isn’t. That said, the sword on the titles doesn’t look like something that would suit Dureena’s style and size. I’m not sure what would have suited her character.
  • If it was a different design, might it have replaced the sword in the titles for season two?
  • You’d have to assume the sword have performed as her ‘power nexus’ and be bonded to her, much like the staff does for Galen.

The Implants:

  • No reference is made to her implants in the script for “To the End of the Line” so that’s no help as to what they do, or what new “powers” they give her. Let me guess… an episode or two would have had them go out of control and threaten the ship?
  • Speculation suggests that if she was whisked away by unknown entities, and returned with amnesia, that on her return she would be thoroughly checked out by Dr Chambers, before being allowed free reign onboard again. Therefore at least Dr Chambers would know of the implants and probably discuss it with Gideon due to the potential threat they might cause.
  • That Dureena has the implants has two implications – that either she did, or did not give consent for them to be implanted. The potential reasons for either could have been very interesting.
  • The notes in “Other Voices Volume 2” describe the implants as being similar to those of the Technomages. Would they have somehow been the “opposite” of the Technomage powers? A light to their dark? That would fit with the overarching themes of the Babylon 5 universe, plus the fact she got them from huge, shiny, white spaceship.
  • In some forms of Arthurian legend, Arthur receives Excalibur from the Lady of the Lake – would this have some bearing on the “White Ship?”

The Forbidden Tech aspect:

  • The episode supposedly “sets up forbidden tech” – does this mean her implants/sword or hints about the revelations about the Technomages to come? Who is forbidding the technology and why?

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

< Previous Episode: The Walls of Hell (Sword Trilogy Part 2)| Next Episode: The End of the Line>

Crusade – The Unproduced Episodes – S01E22 – The End of the Line

   The Enemies Within

   Format: Unproduced Script

   Availability: Was online for a very short time on the “Bookface” website in the early 2000s. Was included in the B5 Books Crusade Script books

   Written by J Michael Straczynski

To be Directed by: Janet Greek

Grade: A-

Spoilers follow

Episode Synopsis

Gideon gets answers he doesn’t like – Both about the ship that destroyed the Cerberus, and what Galen has been hiding from him.

Detailed Episode Synopsis

Ever since the events of “To the Ends of the Earth,” Gideon has been monitoring for the same signal he discovered related to the Shadow hybrid vessel. They discover it again and with Galen’s assistance, determine the point of origin. Gideon changes course to intercept. A crew member (Jensen) discusses the course change with another crew member. On finding out what is happening, he looks concerned.

The Excalibur drops out of Hyperspace in the system in sector 420, which is supposed to be empty and without a jump gate. They enter the system far from their target to avoid raising suspicion. As they approach, Galen detects a minefield that the Excalibur’s sensors would have missed. From its position they determine it was laid only a few hours ago and targeted in their direction. Gideon suspects they have a mole onboard.

Realizing they traced the communications back to him, Jensen activates an implanted bomb to ensure his silence. An inspection of his body brings no answers and his Earthforce record seems uncommonly perfect. Gideon concludes someone associated with the hybrid ship must have deep ties within Earthforce.

As they approach the source of the transmissions (the fourth planet in the system,) they detect some domes on the surface, but no indication of who or what is down there. As they draw nearer, scanners detect fighter ships launching. The Excalibur launches in turn. As the ships close on each other, the fighters are identified as EarthForce Starfuries and Thunderbolts.

Gideon is contacted by Earthforce Major Lee. He orders Gideon to stand down. Gideon decides to do so, then after being told to leave, he tells the Major that as no base is on file, he needs to be sure this is an official Earthforce facility and is going to the surface to meet with the Major. If the Major doesn’t agree, Gideon lets him know he will put out a distress call to all other Earthforce vessels in the area to assist in determining if the Major is a legitimate Earthforce Major. Lee grudgingly accepts Gideon’s request.

Gideon takes a shuttle down, flanked by an escort of the base’s fighters, landing at one of the domes. The interior of the base is completely undecorated and anonymous. Gideon is escorted under armed guard to a room containing the Major.

Lee questions Gideon on why he’s in this sector, when he’s supposed to be in sector 730. Gideon asks why they are. Lee informs him that the place is a need to know R+D facility working on weapons tech for the protection of Earth and her colonies. That is all he is willing to divulge. He threatens Gideon that if he doesn’t turn and leave, someone higher up the chain of command than both of them, will reassign someone more ‘compliant’ to the Excalibur.

Gideon returns to the Excalibur. With the base’s fighters holding position, the Excalibur jumps away to hyperspace. Gideon meets with Galen, and while Gideon is willing to believe that the operation may not be responsible for the destruction of the Cerberus, he needs to find out just what is going on there. Galen is willing to get him in undetected, but points out that Gideon is about to perform espionage against his own military.

Gideon visits and tells Dureena that if he doesn’t return, he wants Matheson to have his datacrystals on the Cerberus incident, and to ask him to finish what Gideon couldn’t.

Galen’s ship lands at the outskirts of the base unobserved, dropping off Gideon, then departs. Entering through maintenance tunnels, Gideon sneaks into the base. Inside is a mile wide cavern, given over to the construction of starships. The starships noticeably incorporate Shadow technology.

Gideon is discovered by a human who is somehow fused or hybridized with a Shadow-like carapace. She lets out an inhuman howl which captures the attention of other hybrids, all of which do the same and point in his direction. He tries to escape, but is captured at gunpoint and ends up in a cell talking to Major Lee once more. He offers him a deal – either he is vanished forever (which has occurred to others who learnt the truth), or he uses his considerable tenacity to help with their project.

Lee tells Gideon, that they are attempting to adapt Shadow technology to make it work with human technology. Lee insinuates that they may even be able to find a cure quicker than Gideon can because of that. Lee admits that only some of the EarthForce hierarchy knows of the project, and that people have been silenced permanently for finding out.

Gideon asks about the Cerberus. Lee tells him that due to the organic nature of Shadow tech, sometimes control subjects go mad and that the Cerberus was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Gideon asks if the hybrid humans outside are also a mistake. The Major won’t explain, but calls Gideon very judgmental, seeing how he is very close to someone else using Shadow technology for a long time – Galen.

He explains the discrepancy in the Technomage technology, why it appears to be so far in advance of human technology. He explains that they took it from the Shadows and that the Technomages weren’t fleeing the Shadows before the war, they were fleeing Earthforce, as they wanted what the Technomages had.

Gideon lies and agrees to join them, but Lee sends for a telepath to ensure his sincerity. At this point Galen blows the door – with Lee and the guards knocked out, Gideon and Galen escape, using a distortion field generated by Galen. As they leave, Galen sees the cavern full of Shadow tech and hybrids. He hands Gideon the staff so that he can enter the ship, while Galen goes to destroy the factory and put the hybrids out of their misery.

Gideon looks back to see Galen using some kind of technology to sheath himself in living metal as he unleashes ribbons of power, destroying the technology in the cavern and causing multiple explosions. Gideon barely makes it to the maintenance tunnel in one piece – Galen catches up, but he’s on the verge of collapse and Gideon drags him outside to Galen’s flyer.

As they leave Gideon confronts Galen. Galen admits that was why the Technomages left. Gideon realizes that Galen was with them to watch him and the rest of Earthforce to discover how much they had succeeded in adapting Shadow Tech. He asks Galen if the only reason he saved him was because of his connection to the technology.

Gideon asks Galen to drop him off at Mars, and tell the Excalibur to meet him there. He’s going to expose the EarthForce conspiracy. Gideon then tells Galen to leave him alone. Gideon gets Eilerson to organize a meeting with the provisional Mars government. As they approach a sniper shoots Gideon in the chest, despite Galen’s best efforts to warn him.

“To be continued”

Review

This episode is more of a slow-burner, but the slow drip of new discoveries mean it’s never boring, it increases the tension until the satisfying destruction of the base giving Gideon some feeling of revenge. The final assassination scene comes across as a little rushed, but would have been a great cliffhanger.

The script follows reasonably predictable lines once EarthForce is seen to be in charge of the operation. You never truly believe Gideon would leave after being ordered to, and his agreement to join the cause is an obvious bluff (He never bluffs, don’t you know) to the viewer. The Major might say he has the best interests of Earth at heart, but he seems to revel in the assassinations, threats and cover-ups throughout the episode. Sadly this removes any shades of grey around his motivations and places him firmly in the “villain” category. Had the Major been shown as regretful of being (in his mind) forced to take these actions, it might have made for more nuance.

What is more shocking and interesting (if somehow you’ve never heard the plot development before, or read the Technomage Trilogy) is that the Technomages use Shadow Technology. Although why they do and where their allegiances truly lie is not gone into in this script, it must be assumed that it would have come to the fore in the seasons to come. Much of the information I believe was woven into Technomage Trilogy of novels – if you’re interested.

Most of the remaining cast get a scene in passing – Chambers conducting an autopsy, Matheson doing his duty and Dureena getting a task from Gideon – but for the most part it’s a strong two-hander for Gideon and Galen.

The “sniper” scene at the end feels a little too over-familiar, but seeing that Gideon actually gets hit in the chest, instead the usual off-screen sound effect, is a decent way to close the season. It leaves you with lots of new information to digest and the implications for the characters, the next season and the show in general.

Crusade Continuity

  • GALENWATCH – Present.
  • No Drakh – Again, no more Drakh. So despite being the supposed “Big Bad” of this show, they only appear in 4 of 25 episodes (if you include A Call to Arms). It’s almost like the Drakh plague was a hook to bring you into the series and it would go on to examine other issues…
  • Date Unknown

Jensen (the mole) has only been onboard for two months – possibly he was assigned by his superiors following Gideon’s discoveries in “To the Ends of the Earth.” It might have been nice to see him in sympathetic role in a previous episode to give some weight to the betrayal.

Dureena has her Sword from the previous episode wrapped up and stored away – apparently it makes a shimmering sound and glows along the edges occasionally.

The black ops Earthforce base also includes a telepath on staff – how the newly re-integrated telepaths fit into the universe of Crusade was never fully defined.

I always thought the Shadow-tech converted Omega destroyers were a bit ridiculous in Babylon 5 (“Between the Darkness and the Light”). We could have recognised the incorporation of Shadow tech without all the spiky protrusions everywhere. The Starfuries and Thunderbolts launched from the secret base are not described as having any Shadow-tech components to them. The B5@20 book has some tantalizing images of what a hybrid Starfury might have looked like and does the concept far more justice. Maybe these would have been seen in the cavern?

The B5@20 book includes concept images of how the somewhat gruesome human/shadow hybrid creatures may have looked (I can’t be the only one reminded of the assorted Ripley clones in Alien Resurrection).

The whole “point and scream” action that the hybrid humans do is lifted straight from the 1970s version of Invasion of the Body Snatchers.

The destruction of the base is the second base they’ve found with links to the hybrid project (after “To the Ends of the Earth”). Possibly the third depending on what the “construction site” was in S01E18.

It has been stated that after being shot, Gideon’s conscience would have been transferred, somehow, to the Apocalypse Box. What the long term implications of this are, isn’t known.

Gideon uses Eilerson’s contacts to set up a meeting with the Mars Provisional Government. While I believe the Earth Alliance government is temporarily located on Mars, I think this means that Gideon goes to meet with the Mars Government, not the EA government, which seems odd.

Speculation Central

Gideon asks Lee about the EAS Cerberus incident. Lee tells him that due to the organic nature of Shadow tech, sometimes control subjects go mad and that the Cerberus was in the wrong place at the wrong time. Due to its location, it seems far more likely that it was dispatched to chase down the Technomages in 2259.

Sector 420. Not sure if there’s a joke there somewhere…

Dureena has the sword “stored and wrapped up” in her quarters. We’re still not sure if this means that it is being hidden or just simply stored in a locker. She covers it before answering the door – which may imply hiding. That it isn’t on show and ready for use, either implies it’s being hidden or that she’s still unsure of what the sword’s purpose is yet.

While Dureena’s sword glowing and shimmering is a cool idea (and hopefully wouldn’t look like a light/dark saber) – Whether it does this for fun, or for a reason (Orcs!) is not stated. It shimmers just before Gideon appears, which I’m sure is just a coincidence… While it might be seen as a little bit clichéd now, the idea of seeing a glowing sword on screen would have been more cool and unique at that time – the release of “The Fellowship of the Ring.” was still a year or so away.

Gideon’s conscience being transferred to the Apocalypse Box. Opens up a gamut of questions:

  • Who or what transfers him there?
  • Why is he transferred there?
  • How long is he there? And does time pass in the same way?
  • What, if anything is in there with him?
  • Does it have it’s own environment inside?
  • Can he communicate with those outside the Box?
  • If he’s restored to his body, is he still Gideon or changed somehow? Does anything come along for the ride (as saw with Matheson)?

There’s a ton of possible answers to all of these questions. Personally, I like the idea that as the Box caused his death, his conscience is sucked in there as a sort of ‘prize’ along with the previous owners. The Box holds their consciences as both a way of sustaining it’s own existence, as well as some sort of database (and why it knows so many ‘secrets’) – although this answer runs a little close to the Soul Hunter philosophy. I’m assuming they somehow keep Gideon’s body in some kind of stasis and he returns to it at some point in the season ahead, but with JMS writing it’s possible that something a little more interesting than that was to come.

Gideon tells Dureena to ransack his room to find the data crystals to pass to Matheson. She’s a thief, Gideon knows this, is she also supposed to find the Apocalypse Box? Due to the piecemeal nature of the scripts up to this point it’s not clear who actually knows Gideon has the Box. Matheson knows, he knew of it before and then it took over his body (part 2 of the Sword trilogy) and at the very least Galen suspects Gideon has something hidden.

(All images are property of Warner Brothers)

<Previous Episode: Untitled (Sword Trilogy Part 3)| Next:  Episode: Little Bugs Have Lesser Bugs (Season 2) >